What are the FCA’s new Sustainability Disclosure Requirements? Phiroza Katrak pkatrak@arlingclose.com

Following consultation, on 28th November the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) released its long-awaited policy framework on Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR) and investment labels.  The FCA’s aim is that financial products that are marketed as sustainable should do as they claim, have more transparency and consistency in reporting and give consumers the ability to understand and differentiate between sustainable funds. 

The lack of standardised terminology for terms such as ‘ESG’, ‘sustainable’ or ‘green’, often used loosely or interchangeably, risked greenwashing and an erosion of trust in a rapidly growing market for sustainable investments.  The objectives of the SDR are therefore to protect consumers, mainly retail investors, through better information and product labelling, enhance market integrity, support competition in financial services and, ultimately, assist with the UK’s target to reach net zero by 2050.

There is staged implementation process:

31.05.2024  The anti-greenwashing rules and guidance, which applies to all FCA-authorised firms who make sustainability-related claims about their products and services, come into force

31.07.2024   Firms can begin to use labels and accompanying disclosures

02.12.2024   Naming and marketing rules come into force

02.12.2025   Ongoing product level and entity level disclosures for firms with assets under management in excess of £50 billion

02.12.2026   Entity level disclosures extended to firms with assets under management in excess of £5 billion

Anti greenwashing

The anti-greenwashing rule applies to all FCA-authorised firms who must ensure that sustainability-related claims are fair, clear and not misleading and are consistent with the profile of the product or service. The rule applies to all communications about the environmental and/or social characteristics of financial products and services and extends to all of the ways in which sustainability could be represented, for example statements, assertions, information, images, policies, strategies, and targets.

Although the FCA’s proposal had been for this rule to come into effect immediately on publication of its SDR policy statement, its implementation has been delayed to May 2024 as the regulator is currently consulting on anti-greenwashing guidance.

The FCA will also be looking very closely at how funds are named. Sustainability-related terms can only be used in product names and marketing provided they use one of the four labels.

Labels

Three labels had initially been proposed, to which a fourth has now been added.  They do not represent a hierarchy.

  1. Sustainability Focus: This label is for products investing mainly in assets that are sustainable for people and/or the planet.
  2. Sustainability Improvers: Here, the objective must be consistent with an aim to invest in assets that have the potential to improve environmental and/or social sustainability in the future. The time period over which the product and/or assets are expected to meet the standard should be identified, including short and medium-term targets for improvement. There should be evidence that the assets have the potential to meet sustainability standards. Stewardship, i.e. active engagement, strategies should support delivery and KPIs should demonstrate progress of the product/assets towards the objective.  
  3. Sustainability Impact: The fund’s or product’s objective must be consistent with an aim to achieve a pre-defined positive, measurable impact in relation to environmental and social objectives. Firms must set out a theory of change and a robust method for measuring and demonstrating the positive impact of both, the assets the product invests in, and the firm's investment activities.
  4. Sustainability Mixed Goals: This label has been added to accommodate funds that invest across a combination of sustainability objectives and strategies. Funds using this label will need to meet the specific criteria for each of the other labels it is invested across.

For all labels, at least 70% of the product’s assets must be pursuing the environmental and/or social sustainability objective, determined using a robust, evidence-based standard, which is an absolute measure of sustainability. The balance assets must not be in conflict with the sustainability objective.

It is encouraging to note the requirement for clarity and brevity (consumer-facing disclosures should not exceed two pages), and prominent placement on any digital mediums through which the product is offered, e.g. webpages, mobile apps.  The information must include the product’s sustainability objective and label, the investment policy and strategy, what will be included or excluded from investment, relevant metrics and where further sustainability information may be accessed.   

Ongoing product reporting - disclosures to be provided annually – will provide investors with information on how the fund’s or product’s pre-contractual aims and commitments set in relation to sustainability are actually being achieved and delivered. 

Related Insights

The Outlook for Green Gilts

ESG Integration

Do Credit Ratings include ESG?